HOME ABOUT US ASK THE RABBI CONTACT US
Chabad of Great Neck
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this


 

The Titanic and Jews

  
 

It was sad when that great ship went down; there were husband and wives, little chillun lost their lives.

 

It was sad – it was sad – it was sad when that great ship went down, hit the bottom – there were husband and wives, little chillun lost their lives – it was sad when that great ship went down.’ We sang the chorus of that song with gusto at our Jewish camp in North Carolina in the 1950s and the lead verse sticks in my memory defining what this was all about. “Oh they built the ship Titanic to sail the ocean blue – and they thought they had a ship that the water couldn’t get through,” but then none of us youngsters knew what that ship was or what happened to it.

I learned faster than some of my friends. On my late summer visits to Bubbie Birshtein in Norfolk Virginia, my mother’s mother, a surprise was in store for me. The Titanic words became real when I was introduced to a man in his forties, Mr. Aks, a family friend, and I was told that he was one of the babies who survived the sinking of the Titanic in 1912.

Amazingly, he was taken from his mother’s arms that terrible night as the ship began to carry its passengers under water and thrown overboard.

He was caught by a woman in a lifeboat, whose last name was Astor. She wrapped him in a blanket since he was only nine months old. Later he was returned to his mother, who did survive.

He kept that blanket as his good luck charm and spent his life in Norfolk where the family settled.

Still, my understanding of the Titanic was minimal even when I graduated college in 1959. I only got the vibes about fifteen years ago when I read a sermon by a rabbi in Atlanta Georgia, not family, who told his congregation on the Shabbat after the disaster in April 1912: “The sinking of the Titanic is an event of great importance to the American Jewish community.” His statement challenged me personally to find some answers. The ones I located are just the tip of the proverbial “iceberg” which took the Titanic down to the depths.

Let us think back, a century ago, to an era with only wireless, a primitive radio and Edison’s phonograph. There were silent films as well. Of course the greatest communication was via the newspapers. Since the actual information about the sinking took a while to reach the press, the Monday headlines read “The great new ship, Titanic, has some problems in the Atlantic: everyone safe.” Second editions that day and all the papers on Tuesday carried the horrible news that at least “1300 passengers have been lost.” In the next few days the descriptions became more vivid as survivors were interviewed.

What struck me was the minimal “Forbes-listing” of that era which pointed out again and again who were the rich who drowned. Number one was Col. John Jacob Astor worth then $150,000,000. Of course, it was his wife who saved the Aks baby. Number two wealth-wise was the copper baron and scion of a noted American Jewish family: Benjamin Guggenheim.

His wealth amounted to $95,000,000.

The only other Jew among the seven men of great wealth who lost their lives was Isidor Straus, a $50,000,000 man, whom we recall from the movie “Titanic” because his wife Ida refused to enter a lifeboat and perished with her husband.

Today we take the counting of wealth as a natural part of our lives.

The recent Forbes list of billionaires included 12 Israelis and many more Jews around the world. One hundred years ago Jews knew that people like Guggenheim and Straus were wealthy but there was no sense of how large that personal wealth was. Moreover, WASPish Americans only knew wealthy Jews as usurpers who made do with large interest rates. When those numbers appeared again and again in April and May 1912 – American Jews were amazed and Christians too. By the end of that first week after the catastrophe, The New York Times began reporting memorial services at Temple Emanuel and Temple Beth El in the city specifically for Guggenheim and Straus. We now know that at least 100 American synagogues throughout the USA held such services for the “big two” but also for individuals with local connections who lost their lives. The drama in the Jewish community played out in a different manner.

The best-known American Orthodox Jew of that second decade of the 20th century was Cantor Yossele Rosenblatt.

He acted instinctively with the great heart he had. For RCA Victor Records he cut an El Mole Rahamim for the unfortunate ones who were gone. You can pick it up easily on the internet by putting in his name. 100 years later we listen to Rosenblatt’s moving melodic musical interpretation. For his prayer he included in Hebrew, something new for that period, “for the people of the Titanic who drowned in the sea and are gone to their eternal home.”

That recording sold quickly – $150,000 was raised because Rosenblatt donated all his rights. Those funds, a very large sum, was contributed to the fund for the families who lost loved ones on the Titanic.

One Yiddish paper wrote, “the sinking of the Titanic was a tragedy that left no heart untouched.”

As the selfless act of love and devotion of Ida Straus, dying together with her husband Isidor, became better known, both Jews and Christians praised her to the sky. She was a woman of valor – following the words of Ruth to Naomi, “where you die – I will die.”

Pictures of Ida and pictures of Ida and Isidor filled the press.

They were the heroes of that tragedy and everyone knew that they were Jews, noted philanthropists whose love was incredible.

A New York Yiddish lyricist, Solomon Small, 1868-1943, did not hesitate for a moment.

He penned a song entitled Der Naser Kever (The Watery Grave.) Rosenblatt recorded the song and the sheet music was published with a moving illustration. On the cover one saw a drawing of the stricken ship. Floating above it are the spirits of the personages of Ida and Isidor Straus. An angel can be seen placing a wreath on the heads of the loving couple who are joined in an embrace.

We should listen to a few of the poignant words of that song.

“Standing there... are the thousands who know that death will dash them forever. They cry out.”

Here we can feel the anguish.

“Save yourselves... into the boats quickly women take a place there.” Now the song focuses on Ida. “But listen to that woman soul – I won’t stir from the spot, I’ll die here with my husband.”

The song concludes: “Let small and great honor the name of Ida Straus.”

From those whose Yiddish knowledge is extensive, I am told that the words captured the feelings of thousands – perhaps millions of people at that time.

The rabbi in Atlanta concluded his sermon with these memorable thoughts. “We have wept for all the victims of the Titanic together. Now we must interweave into our own lives that moving devotion of Ida for Isidor. Only then we will demonstrate what these two and all those who rest in the watery depths mean to us. May their souls be bound up in the bonds of life eternal.”
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this

Food For Thought
PM: Throughout history, Jews have overcome all enemies
Israel kicks off 64th Independence Day celebrations
Muslim, Zionist and Proud
Your gravestone is covered with hundreds of rocks, each one carrying a message of love.
Why we fight for Israel
The Holocaust began with boycots
Welcome To Belgistan -- The New Muslim Capital Of Europe
Kiev Assault Victim Regains Consciousness
IDF boards ship allegedly smuggling arms to Gaza
Egyptians terminate gas flow to Israel
Saudi hacker who targeted Jewish sites dies at 28
Occupy Wall Street's Facebook Page
Chabad Lubavitch News
Israel, Cyprus gas finds spur Mediterranean race
Australian Prime Minister does it again!!
Israel Gearing Up to Attack Iran?
The Titanic's Kosher Kitchen
Ship with Iranian arms seized at sea
The Titanic and Jews
A Visit to the ‘Soviet Jerusalem’
Terrorists freed in Schalit deal return to terror
Give Rise to the Heroism of Those Who Showed Bravery During the Holocaust
Meditation through a Sea of Reeds
Analysis: Israel’s options in Sinai are limited
Cairo - Israeli Embassy in Egypt Calls Off Seder
Grad rocket slams into southern city of Eilat
Israeli-US anti-missile drill back on track
FRANCE UNCOVERS PLOT TO KIDNAP JEWISH JUDGES'
German trial shows al-Qaida targeted Europe economy
Is Jerusalem the Capital of Israel?
TORAH CAFE PASSOVER 2012
Condo Owner In Fight Over Mezuza: 'I'm Bullied And Saddened'
Baku grants Israel use of its air bases'
Journalist arrested by PA goes on hunger strike
Frankfurt elects 1st Jewish Mayor since Holocaust
Israeli woman is "Europe's top young researcher"
Autism Rates Up; Screening, Better Diagnosis Cited
WHY PAY MORE? GET IT DONE TODAY!
Why do we spill the wine when we mention the Ten Plagues on Pesach night
Over 100,000 Urge President Peres to Use His Leverage to Get Pollard Out
Brooklyn Co-Op votes down Israel boycott
Is Silence good for you?
Thousands Attend Jerusalem Burial of Terror Victims
Little Gabriel Was Named for Mumbai Victim
PURE EVIL: Terrorist Dead After Jumping from Window
The New Egyptian Parliament Takes Aim at the Camp David Accords
Mission Impossible
Intel Chief: World Jewry Faces Growing Terror Threat
French Jews Fear Another Terror Wave
French Police Close In on Toulouse Killer
Gaddafi’s Advanced Anti-Aircraft Missiles Are Now Pointed at Israel
What Makes You Jealous?
No Disproportionate Reaction to Gaza Flare-Up
2 Grad rockets fired toward Beersheba
The Situation in Beersheba is Unbearable
Israeli PM Netanyahu: We'll Continue Striking
Leader of Group Behind Schalit Kidnapping Killed by Israel Airstrike
Kids in South learning state can't defend itself
Rivlin cancels delegation after US refuses MK visa
Palestinian killed after soldier stabbed in W. Bank
Netanyahu: Attack on Iran not immediately in offing
How can one always just smile and be happy?
Nazi Hunter Beate Klarsfeld Planning Run for President in Germany
New energy sources for LI under review
Putin's Return: Why It Matters
Personal Regards From Israel
C'tee created to enforce building demolitions
Speaker Quinn Voices Support for NYPD Monitoring of Muslims
On the Site of Kristallnacht
Drunk Woman Hands Over Car Keys to Boyfriend
Police Arrest Suspect W. Bank Car-Jacking Wave
Protect Mount of Olives, Americans Tell Knesset
IDF strikes targets in Gaza after rockets hit South
Several police hurt as hundreds riot at Temple Mount
Man Buys Safe for $122, Finds $26,000 Inside
Thailand Police Chief: Iranians Planned To Attack Israelis
White House Hits Congressional Roadblock in UNESCO Funding for Palestinians
Kever Rochel and Machpelah No Longer “Israeli Sites”
Arrow missile defense system successfully tested
A Rabbi’s Teachings on Recovery Find a Wide Audience
Iranian Calls to Destroy Jewish People Unparalleled Since Nazi Germany
Facebook Replaces Israel with Palestine
Israel’s Postal Service Releases Tanya Stamp
Never Too Late: US Couple in 90s Makes Aliyah
CNN Denies Accusations of Anti-Semitism
Oprah Winfrey Amazed by Jewish Values During Interview With Chasidic Families
California Professor Cites 'Virulent' Campus Anti-Semitism
Iran must attack Israel by 2014
Scientists: Sound can activate ‘sight’ for blind
New Checklist Helps Women Prepare more Easily for Mikvah
70 Settlements to be Excluded from Priority List
Man Faces Indefinite Detention for Refusal to Give Get
The Growing Anti-Jewish Hate
'Son of Hamas' Visits Chabad, Draws Large Crowd
Chabadniks in India Deny Espionage Charge
Oprah Goes Orthodox (Sort Of)
Pilot Sees Chabad Everywhere
Israel among world's most educated countries
Kosher Meals Now Available on Capitol Hill
Azerbaijan foils Iranian-Hizballah terror strike against Israel targets and Habad
Delegitimization of Israel is new anti-Semitism
IDF covert operations rise significantly over past year
Israel among top 3 in cyber attack defense
Children with autism have lower levels of HDL
Hamas Lawmakers Arrested At Red Cross In Jerusalem
Terrorist Tries to Attack at Patriarchs’ Cave in Hevron
A-G orders investigation into Jerusalem Mufti
Bloody towel leads to thief's capture after 1 year
Anti-Semitism Remains Deeply Rooted in Germany
Meet the Holocaust Baby
Do water and earth have feelings?
IDF hits terrorists placing bombs near Gaza fence
U.S. Jewish Population Reaches 6.5 Million
Alaska: That Great Big Jewish Land
The Kidney Matchmaker
Hizbullah Planned Mumbai-Style Attack on Chabad of Bangkok
IDF preparing for major Gaza operation within months
The Burning Bush - Be Attentive in Life
Iran Sentences American Man to Death in CIA Case
Israeli Archaeologists Find 1,500-Year-Old “Hechsher”
Iranian Nuclear Scientist Killed In Car Bomb Blast
Video - Tefillin Prompts Scare On Plane
Why is the conflict in Israel?
Unconditional Love and Kisses
Mending Fences Made Easier by Focus on Love
Prisoner exchange deals put us on slippery slope
UK warns Iran: Close Hormuz at your own peril
Scholarly world abuzz over Jewish scrolls find
Scrolls raise questions as to Afghan Jewish history
Seeking Kin: An Israeli Finds his American Cousins
Israeli Airstrikes Kill Gaza Militant
The Iranian Schindler who saved Jews from the Nazis
American College Students Light Up Israeli Army Base
Motivation to kidnap IDF soldiers up since Schalit deal
Air Force kills Gazan terrorist in missile attack
The Genius of Steve Jobs
White House Official Lights National Menorah
Why Don't We See Miracles?
Hanukkia Lit in Spot Hitler Decreed Final Solution
Global Affairs: All change at Red Square
IDF must be vigilant on northern front amid Syria unrest
'Depth Corps' a sign of Israel's regional threats
Germany criticizes Israel for settlement building
US commander visits Israel to finalize missile drill
Navy completing secret 2 year submarine upgrade
Smoking related to non-melanoma skin cancer
Stem cell research yields blood restoring vessels
Question of the Week
Head of Reform Movement to Write About Chabad
Historic 'Baal Shem Tov' Siddur Sold At Sotheby’s For Over $500K
Extremists Arrested In Italy For Plotting Against Jewish Community
IDF uses ‘Black Swan’ to train cadets
Leadership or solo-mission
German Neo-Nazis Sold Anti-Semitic Monopoly Game
Russian Spring: Thousand Protest Against Putin
Why Donors Like Chabad
Challenge OR OPPORTUNITY?
Israel Threatens To Cut Off Power, Water To Gaza
Controversial Islamic Center Near Ground Zero Quietly Advances
Prague - World’s Oldest Known Holocaust Survivor, Turns 108
Israel Has One of the World's Highest Life Expectancy
Germany to provide Israel with 6th submarine
The Making of a Chief Rabbi
Mysterious explosion rocks Iranian city of Isfahan
Rockets Fired from Lebanon Land in Northern Israel
IDF fires on Lebanon
Chief Rabbi Pushing for Import of Organic Goose That Tastes Like Pork
King Herod Did Not Complete Construction of Kotel
Iran strike aftermath couldn't be as bad as nuclear Iran For 15 Years Goes Free
LOST TRIBE in Papua New Guinea
Chief Rabbi Blames Apple for Selfish Society
The Polish Airliner Miracle
Celebrating the Rebbe Rashab's Birthday and Legacy
Anti-Semitism in Flatbush Continues
Iran faces big power pressure, IAEA wants mission
US election increases chances of Israeli strike on Iran
Down and Dirty in Thailand
Romney: War with Iran Possible
Question of the Week
Rainbow in the Night: Keeping the Holocaust Alive
Vandals Burn Cars, Leave 'KKK' Graffiti in Jewish Nabe
DO IT TODAY
Dmitriy Salita Reflects on Finding God in the Ring
Jerusalem Is in Israel, Argues Nathan Lewin
Israel - Two Thousand Year Old Mikva Found Near Beith Shemesh
Thousands of Children Tour Restored Tel Aviv Shul
IAEA confirms Iran worked on building nuclear bomb
Canada Cuts Funding for UNESCO
Chief Rabbi Delivers Senate Prayer
ADL: Anti-Semitism on the Rise in America
Report: U.K. & U.S. Drawing Up Plan to Attack Iran
Soul On Fire - Reb Michoel Ber Weissmandl
UK speeding up planning for potential Iran attack
Question of the Week Nov. 3 2011
A Jewish Spin on Snoop Dog
Supreme Court Allowing Removal of Roadside Crosses
Rockets from Gaza hit Beersheba, Sderot, Sha'ar Hanegev
US Cuts Funding For UNESCO After Palestinian Vote
Stubborn or Just Ungrateful
Arrest Warrant Issued For the Wife of Yasser Arafat
Second Israeli Prisoner Released
Grad rocket fired from Gaza Strip explodes near Ashdod
Palestinian Envoy Booted Out
The Rebbe's Dollar and Gilad Shalit
Torch Cams to Give Masses View from Lady Liberty
Gilad Shalit Returns Home
Outrage: This Man to Be Released!?
Freed prisoners who return to terror do so at own risk
Schalit: I thought I'd be held captive for years to come
How Many Directions You Shake the Lulav
Hamas's Mashaal: Prisoner deal is 'national achievement'
Background: In book, PM warned not to release terrorists
Palestinians celebrate prisoner deal across territories
Cabinet approves deal with Hamas: Schalit to return home
The Schalit deal: 1,027 prisoners to be freed in 2 stages
CIA drone Kills U.S.-Born Al-Qaeda Terrorist Who Inspired Times Sq Plot
Israel Rejects Criticism Of New Jerusalem Housing
Celebrating High Holy Days in Afghanistan
Netanyahu Cites Rebbe’s Directive in UN Address
New Details: Hiker Released From Iran Is Jewish
The Ohel
US delegation walks out on Ahmadinejad UNGA speech
Obama tells Israelis what they’ve been waiting to hear
Oversized Mezuzah Named for Presidential Candidate
Historic Mikvah to Be Displayed at Holland Museum
Google Brings Jerusalem, Israel To Virtual Tourist
Rebbe’s Pre-1940 Note Shines Spotlight on Scholarly Indices
Turner victory highlights Obama's slippage among Jews
Why Shofar on Rosh Hashanah?
Noted Political Hack Sheinkopf Becomes A Chabad Rabbi
UAV that can reach Iran
Why We Need Israel
The 9-11 Diary: Hitler Vs. Obama
US Says It Will Veto Palestinian Statehood Bid At UN
Question of the Week
Felix Zandman and Vishay
They smashed our hearts and souls
NYPD Eyed 250-Plus Mosques, Student Groups
Documents Expose US Wiretaps of Israeli Embassy
Liberal Jew Spied on Israel to Prevent Attack on Iran
Israeli President Visits Chabad School in Jerusalem
Happiness is a Serious Problem
Lessons for the Rest of Us From the Success of Chabad
Muslims, police scuffle at Rye Playland
You Don't Need Time or Money
The Haimish Line
Top Bundestag lawmaker to Germany: Boycott Durban III
IDF develops doctrine for accurate sniper fire
Doctors: New Cancer Pill Gives Hope
Question of the Week
Tehran to sue Russia over breached S-300 contract
Miracle Recovery of Terror Rocket Victim
Book Adds Details On IKEA Founder's Nazi Links
The Wisdom of the Rooster
Australia will not attend Durban III conference
Miracle in Ashdod Synagogue: Grad Fails to Explode
UN Fails to Condemn Eilat Terror Attacks
Israeli Killed, Dozens Hurt by More Than 50 Rockets Fired from Gaza
US intel investigating al-Qaida link to Eilat attacks
7 dead in terror attacks; IDF still looking for terrorists
IDF strikes Gaza in response to attacks; 6 reported dead
Israeli Military Medics Evacuate Wounded
Terror Attacks On Multiple Targets Near Eilat
For Daniel Agami, 9/11 Attack Was a Call to Service
‘Tenth Jew’ Dies, Only Nine Left
21st dinner
Logan Airport to Start Using Israeli-Style Screening
Supreme Court to Hear Menachem Zivotofsky Vs. Hillary Clinton
Glenn Beck: "Don't ever call it 'West Bank' again"
Palestinian Grad rocket explodes near Kiryat Gat
Iran sees further delay in starting up nuclear plant
Torah Cafe Picks
Riots Spread to Jewish Community of Stamford Hill
Chabad rabbi released after Ecuador kidnapping
Jewish Group To Get Congress to Recognize Heroism of Raoul Wallenberg
Joe Lieberman releases book about the beauty of Shabbat
As London Burns, Riots Spread to Jewish Communities
How Strong Are You?
OBAMA'S RAMADAN DINNER GUEST LIST
Soul Mates: Secrets from Kabbalah for Eternal Relationships
Tens of Thousands Mourn Murdered Rabbi Abuchatzeira

Homepage - FC2.jpg

Homepage - SHA2.jpg

Homepage - HS2.jpg

Homepage - Camp2.jpg

Homepage - BMC2.jpg

Homepage - Donate2.jpg

Homepage - JLI2.jpg